The Hiring Horizon
Seven Insightful Interview Questions to Ask Prospective Employees
July 7, 2025 · 6 min read
Close to twenty years in recruitment adds up to a genuinely large number of interviews. The exact tally is beside the point, but the pattern that emerges from that many conversations is not: the right questions reveal exceptional talent far more reliably than the standard script does.
Interviewing well is not just about filling a vacancy. It is about identifying people who will thrive in the specific role, align with the culture, and grow alongside the team. Here are seven questions worth adding to your own interviews, and what they are actually designed to reveal.
“Tell me about a problem you prevented, not just one you solved.”
This shifts the focus from reactive problem-solving to proactive thinking. Most candidates arrive ready to talk about how they fixed something. Fewer have a ready example of stopping a problem before it started, and that gap is revealing in itself. Listen for initiative, ownership, and genuine critical thinking rather than a rehearsed anecdote.
“What have you taught yourself recently, without anyone asking you to?”
In a fast-changing, increasingly hybrid world of work, self-directed learning is close to essential. This question explores curiosity and intrinsic motivation to grow outside of formal training. Look for genuine enthusiasm and self-awareness in the answer, not just a list of courses.
“What would you change about how your current team operates, and why hasn’t it happened yet?”
This taps directly into analytical thinking and a candidate’s ability to see improvement opportunities. Strong candidates tend to answer this one with real energy, often including what they tried, why it did not land, and what they learned from that. It is one of the most informative questions on this list.
“What actually motivates you at work, beyond the obvious answers?”
This moves past the standard strengths-and-weaknesses territory into genuine values and drivers. Understanding what motivates someone intrinsically, versus what they think you want to hear, tells you a lot about whether your environment will let them thrive.
“Where do you want this role to have taken you in two years?”
A future-focused question that reveals goal-setting ability, clarity on the role, and genuine ambition. It also shows whether a candidate has really thought through what success in this specific position looks like, rather than giving a generic career answer.
“Tell me about a time feedback genuinely stung. How did you handle it?”
This explores emotional intelligence and resilience directly. Look for candidates who treat feedback as useful information rather than a personal attack, who stay composed under scrutiny, and who focus on what they changed rather than who they blamed.
“What would you want to understand in your first two weeks here?”
This uncovers a candidate’s priorities when starting fresh, and their genuine approach to integration. A strong answer often comes with thoughtful questions back to you, or a clear sense of how they would build relationships and understand the role quickly.
Interviews are more than a tick-the-box exercise. Used well, they are the best tool you have for uncovering the qualities that actually make someone right for your team, not just qualified on paper.
About Recruitment Labs
Recruitment Labs is a boutique search firm specialising exclusively in accounting & finance recruitment across Australia and New Zealand. For twenty years we've helped businesses build high-performing finance teams, and helped finance professionals find roles that fit their skills, goals and values.
Keep Reading
More from The Hiring Horizon.
You’re Not Overqualified. You’re Mispositioned.
“Overqualified” is rarely honest feedback. Why senior finance candidates get filtered out for it, and the reframe that actually gets you the role.
Read Article
Six things Boards actually evaluate when hiring a CFO
Six things boards actually evaluate when hiring a CFO, and what finance leaders should prepare for beyond the technical brief.
Read Article
Beyond the Box-Ticking: How to Get Real Value from Reference Checks
Most reference checks produce legal-safe noise, not signal. Here's how to get real value from the process.
Read Article